Ask Mr. Artist Guy: Should I Buy A Laptop Or Dekstop Computer?


Illustrator Doug Jones writes:

I have always had a tower type computer but now I am wondering if maybe I should go for a MacBook Pro as my main computer. Is there any reason to have the large tower type computers anymore?

A great question. I had to do a little research to answer this one. I’m fortunate enough to own both a powerful desktop machine and a laptop, and I use both regularly. Like many creative types I’ve been a devoted Mac user for several years, so I’m pretty clueless as to what’s available in the PC world. But I’m pretty sure most of what I have to say is just as true for users of either platform.

I’m not an expert on computers, so someone else may give you different advice. But as a commercial artist who works digitally, here’s my two cents. There are several issues to consider:

Portability. With a laptop you aren’t tied down to your studio. You can work on projects literally anywhere. I have a laptop and a portable Cinitq (see my review) which I use to take freelance work with me when I travel so that I can still meet my client deadlines. Last week I had a bad cold and, thanks to my laptop I was able to keep working while lying in bed. I even know of some artists who own tablet PC’s (a form of laptop that lets you draw on the screen) and have taken them out to malls and subways just to sketch. A laptop gives you tremendous freedom that a desktop machine simply can’t match.

Elbow Room. A laptop doesn’t take up much room on your desk, and if you need to clear off some room you can simply fold it up and tuck it away. Desktop machines, by contrast, take up significantly more space. But unless you are working in the corner of a one-room apartment, this shouldn’t be too big of an issue.

Price. Laptops are generally cheaper than their desktop counterparts. On the low end, the MacBook (Apple’s low-end laptop) is about $100 cheaper than the iMac (Apple’s low-end desktop machine). Personally I wouldn’t recommend a MacBook or iMac for a professional artist/animator/graphics person because they are so lacking in horsepower. For graphics work you should look at Apple’s high-end laptop, the MacBook Pro (which starts at $1,999) and their high-end desktop machines, the Mac Pro (which starts at $2,799, not including the monitor). You’ll notice that with the high-end machinery there’s a much bigger price gap between the laptop and the desktop machine. However, like most things you get what you pay for. Consider…

Horsepower. Up until a few years ago, laptops were waaaaay behind their desktop counterparts in terms of power and speed. Thanks to technological advances that gap has narrowed significantly, but it’s still there. The basic MacBook Pro comes with a 2.2 GHz processor and 120GB hard drive. The basic Mac Pro starts with a two 8-core 2.8GHz processors and 320GB hard drive. Both machines can be upgraded to be faster and more powerful for a marginal increase in cost.

How fast or powerful a computer is depends a lot on what you are asking it to do, and the intricacies of how a computer works are beyond the scope of my expertise. Suffice it to say that if you are doing a lot of graphics work (i.e. Photoshop) a modern laptop can hold its own and will definitely get the job done, but you will notice an improvement in speed and flexibility when working on a comparable desktop machine. It might just be my imagination, but it seems like I do a little more thumb-twiddling with my MacBook Pro.

If you want more details, here’s a more tech-centered comparison of the Mac Pro vs. the MacBook Pro.

Color Accuracy (or lack thereof). Laptop screens are notorious for their shifting color. Tilt your head just a little to the left or the right and the colors will immediately shift. If you are a stickler for color, a laptop can drive you bonkers. With a desktop machine there are some very nice, very large, very high-res monitors available which, with a little calibrating, can give you brilliant, spot-on color.

Screen “Real Estate”. Laptop screens are pretty tiny. Open a few palettes in Photoshop and suddenly you can find your working area reduced to a tiny small eight-inch square. With a large desktop monitor, by contrast, you can have all your palettes open, have several images open at once, and still be able to navigate everything efficiently. I have a 23″ Apple cinema display, and if I’m working on a large project like an 11×17 layout, I can pretty much see what it will look like at actual size. With a laptop everything always feels tiny and cramped. To help alleviate the problem you can buy a second display to hook up to your laptop, but then you lose the portability factor.

Expandability. You can add more RAM to your laptop (although not as much as you can add to a Mac Pro) and I’m pretty sure you can swap out a bigger hard drive if you want, but that’s about it. If you want to have a souped of computer with extra add-ons (i.e. a faster video card, a second internal hard-drive, the ability to watch TV on your computer, etc.), you’ll need to buy a desktop machine. Desktops also have more USB and Firewire ports for attaching printers, scanners, webcams, external hard drives, etc.

Which machine you purchase is up to you and your specific working style and needs. One final thought I would offer has to do with the issue of longevity. Whichever computer you buy, you can figure that in three to four years it will be obsolete, or at least start to act sluggish. That’s just the reality of technology. My approach has always been to buy the fastest, most powerful computer I can afford so that in 3-4 years it will still be marginally functional, and I can still make do for a longer period if need be. And during those 3-4 years my computer will be a little faster and more powerful than it otherwise would be. If I’d bought a smaller, slower computer three years ago, it’s would be reeeaaaally small and slow now.

Thanks to Doug Jones for the question. Got a question or a blog topic suggestion? Ask Mr. Artist Guy!



7 thoughts on “Ask Mr. Artist Guy: Should I Buy A Laptop Or Dekstop Computer?

  1. I think laptops are finally at the stage where they can be considered desktop replacements. I would recommend them over a desktop.

    For PC users you actually get more for your money buying a desktop. But I think the benifits of a laptop outweigh the cost difference.

    I’ve been using a 17″ HP laptop with 256 video memory and 2 gigs of ram.(It even came with a TV tuner and built in webcam. The tuner is great for recording shows like a TIVO.) I use mine connected to a Cintiq so the monitor color is not an issue. I’ve used this setup for a couple years now and have found no difference in preformance compared to a Desktop. I use Flash, Photoshop, Maya.

    Important upgrades you must have are as much Video Memory as you can get usually 512 on a laptop. As much ram as you can get 3 Gigs is the max for Vista. You can upgrade to Vista 64 bit and get up too 8 gigs (I think) but that is probably overkill for most users.

    Here is the next laptop I have been eyballing for my end of year tax right off. it has a 20.1 inch monitor so it really is a desktop replacement.

    HP Pavilion HDX Entertainment Notebook PC

  2. Maybe this qualifies as another question, but as long as we are discussing laptops. Do you have a certain way you set up your laptop work area?
    For instance, do you find a table to lay out your stuff like a desktop? I use a small wacom tablet, but seems like I still have to have that paper on a desk feeling to draw. It’s even harder to imagine using the bigger wacom tablets.(doesn’t mean I don’t still want one though) 🙂
    I guess what I was wondering is, do you draw with a slant or flat on the desk top?


  3. Scott,

    With my laptop I generally work with it “on the road”, and occasionally in bed or on the living room couch. Most of my work is done on my desktop Mac and large Cintiq. You can see my setup at my studio tour here.

  4. I am a “Geek” (tech blogger and PC Help & Support tech) and would like to add my two cents to this question.
    First, congratulations! I found no technical errors or ‘urban legends’ in the information presented. So, this question becomes one of either “bang for your buck” (always a desktop, and always a PC) or lifestyle.

    In my experience: unless you are a “road warrior”, and you spend more time in airports and hotels than you do at home, your first (primary) computer should be a desktop– with a keyboard that fits you, and the largest monitor your work area (and budget) allows.. maybe even two monitors side-by-side.

    One further thing, the “desktop replacement” types of notebooks– with their large, bright screens and high-end components, are real battery drainers (some are lucky to go two hours on a charge) and suggest that it will be well worth the cost to ‘upgrade’ the battery.

  5. Pingback: Mini Printers » Blog Archive » Ask Mr. Artist Guy: Should I Buy A Laptop Or Dekstop Computer …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s